i.e: burger's, Italian, Mike's
New York, NY | Soho, NYC

The Old Fashioned

American (Traditional), Breakfast & Brunch, Salad

23 N Pinckney St

(608) 310-4545

theoldfashioned.com

Heidi L.
Such a cute interior. They are very accomodating with substitutions. I got the Number 29 (which wasn't too spicy) with a side of curds and ranch (~$12.50),...read more
Vik C.
The Old Fashioned is a Madison classic and reviewing it is like reviewing Huck Finn or Merchant of Venice. One is not going to add any new insight and...read more
Yoon P.
Love the ambience and how cozy it is. Also, they have some of the best burgers in town alongside Dotty's and DEFINITELY the best cheese curds. Don't let...read more
Kristen
: Very disappointing. Food arrived soggy and cold. Salad consisted of lettuce and lettuce only. Dressing was runny. Sauces for cheese curds were not as ordered. Extremely overpriced. Delivery fee was ridiculous, especially when food showed…read more
Jennifer B
Old Fashioned is a Madison favorite for sure!: This place is very hard to get in to at almost any time so I've only been a few times, but the food is always great including the brunch. They have breaded home fries that are great! Highly recommended!read more
missmimimao
Good burgers, tasty salads, large servings, super friendly staff: My friend took me here on my visit to Madison. I ordered the pulled pork sandwich and salad: absolutely loved the salad, which, though basic, was fresh and tasty, but thought the sandwich had lots of room for improvement. We also shared…read more
Katie C
Old Fashioned is Awesome: Love the Old Fashioned. It has a great atmosphere and is right down by the capital building. Has good drinks and good food. A great place to meet up with friends.read more
OldSkool
I love everything about this place. The owners have hit t...: I love everything about this place. The owners have hit the nail on the head with great food at the right...read more
ericatmeow
A Must Stop for Visitors: The Old Fashioned is based on the traditional food and spirits of Wisconsin. You can find all sorts of...read more
cleman79
Very cool place.: Very cool place. (1) No. 30: House Burger w/ Cole Slaw - very good. Cheese curds appetizer excellent. House...read more
Scott W
GREAT FOOD AND Atmosphere: Wonderful experience, great location, and the specials are outstanding. Always busy, get there early or you will have to wait. The wait is well worth it!read more

Map

Photos for The Old Fashioned

Powered by

    deals for Madison, WI

    $40 for $57
    942 Williamson St, Williamson - Marquette, Madison, WI 53703
    (3 reviews)
    $20 for $30
    1821 S Park St, Bram's Addition, Madison, WI 53713
    (10 reviews)
    $15 for $30
    Best Western Plus InnTowner & Highland Club, 2424 University Ave, Regent, Madison, WI 53726
    (3 reviews)
    $50 for $60
    6713 Odana Rd, Madison, WI 53719
    (27 reviews)
    $15 for $30
    1865 Northport Dr, Sherman, Madison, WI 53704
    $15 for $20
    100 East Holum St, DeForest, WI 53532
    (63 reviews)
    $20 for $25
    320 N Parker Dr, Janesville, WI 53545
    (14 reviews)
    $35 for $40
    404 Broadway, Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965
    (3 reviews)
    $5 for $10
    507 Madison St, Beaver Dam, WI 53916
    (6 reviews)
    $45 for $50
    1414 Vino Ln, Jefferson, WI 53549
    (10 reviews)
    $40 for $100
    Rockford, IL 61103